The Mystery of “Absalom’s Tomb” – Part 1

At the base of the Mount of Olives, in the valley of Kidron, just outside the city walls of Jerusalem is a striking rock-cut tomb that has been commonly called for centuries, the “Tomb of Absalom”. Passerby would traditionally throw stones at it and fathers of disobedient children would bring them there to show what happened to rebellious sons.

The attribution of the monument as the tomb of Absalom comes from the passage at 2 Samuel 18:18, ” Now Absalom, while he was alive, had taken and set up for himself a pillar in the Valley of the King, for he said: “I have no son to preserve the memory of my name.” So he named the pillar after himself, and it is called Absalom’s Monument to this day.

The Valley of the King in that verse is taken to be the valley of Kidron, just outside the city walls of old Jerusalem. The first century Jewish historian Josephus reported that Absalom’s Monument was “two stades [370 m; 1,214 ft] distant from Jerusalem.” (Jewish Antiquities, VII, 243 [x, 3]) So the monuments placement in the Valley of Kidron is plausible. But the Biblical and archeological evidence shows that the so-called “Tomb of Absalom” was neither his tomb nor his monument. Two questions arise. How do we know that it couldn’t belong to Absalom and second, if it didn’t belong to Absalom, who did it belong too?

Absalom cropped

Joab slays Absalom.

According to the account in 2 Kings, when the brief but bloody civil war in the young kingdom ended, its instigator Absalom was dead and his father and rival King David was in mourning. The vain and entitled Absalom, executed by King David’s general Joab while hanging from the branches of a large tree, was denied a royal burial and thrown into a pit in the forest of Ephraim with stones piled over his body in a “big heap”. (2 Kings 18:17)

Absalom was buried far from Jerusalem proving that Absalom’s Monument near Jerusalem was not his tomb, nor was it intended to be. 2 Samuel 2:18 says the purpose of the monument was to “preserve the memory” of his name. It was a monument to his considerable ego.

Absalom resizedThe archeological evidence shows that the tomb in the Kidron Valley (and it was a tomb) was made during the first century CE, which is approximately 1000 years after the death of Absalom. It survived the destruction of Jerusalem by the Roman’s in 70 C.E, in spite of the fact that the Romans deliberately destroyed Judean monuments like the tombs of the kings and famously, the Temple. It is by far the grandest tomb to survive in the Kidron valley so it is no surprise that centuries later, people identified the ancient tomb as Absalom’s Monument.

So if it didn’t belong to Absalom, who did it belong too? Inscriptions on the monument have only deepened the mystery. One inscription discovered in 2003 reads, “This is the tomb of Zachariah, the martyr, the holy priest, the father of John.” This refers to the father of John the Baptist (Luke 1:13). However this is considered to be a “secondary use” inscription from the Byzantine era, written at least 3 centuries later when Christian monks residing in Jerusalem commemorated important Christian figures by attributing a connection between them and existing tombs or buildings.

Inside tomb

Inside the tomb.

The same goes for another inscription found in 2003 that partially quotes Luke 2:25, “And look! there was a man in Jerusalem named Simeon, and this man was righteous and devout, waiting for Israel’s consolation“. Again the inscription is centuries younger than the monument. Zachariah and Simeon are no more connected to the monument than was Absalom.

The original occupant of the tomb remains a mystery, but a theory proposed in 2013 by a world renowned Israeli archeologist offers a startlingly plausible answer. Dr. Gabriel Barkay proposes that the monument did not belong to Absalom, or Zechariah father of John nor Simeon but it did likely belong to someone else well familiar to Bible students.

To be continued!

Photo credits:

The tapestry entitled, “The Death of Absalom” was woven in 1817 at the Royal Tapestry Factory in Madrid, under the guidance of its director Don Livinio Stuyck and Vandergoten . {{PD}} Wikimedia Commons

Interior of “Absalom’s Pillar”. Photo by the American Colony (Jerusalem). Matson (G. Eric and Edith) Photograph collection at the Library of Congress. {{PD}} Wikimedia Commons

Other photos by author.

 

 

 

One thought on “The Mystery of “Absalom’s Tomb” – Part 1

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s